{this cool photo of Notre Dame taken by Jill}
On Sunday we all went to church (last week only Marc went -- we were all too jet-lagged, but he felt obligated to go for his students). Since we last were here, they have combined two branches to form a ward. It was nice to see that they have a French bishop, too, as so often the leadership is made up of visiting Americans.
The makeshift chapel in the institute building was filled to overflowing, something I had never seen before in Paris. Another recent innovation is the addition of headsets that can be used to listen to a live English translation, done by one of the missionaries. They ran out, so my boys didn't get any, but I think it was a great relief to Lucas, who was concerned about not understanding anything and had prayed that they would have an English meeting (we told him they sometimes do).
We discovered that they also conduct an English Sacrament Meeting when there is a demand for it -- there was on Sunday, so Lucas was thrilled. It was an interesting meeting, made up largely of tourists just passing through, and a few families who are living here. It was testimony meeting, and we heard some interesting ones. There seemed to be a theme to the meeting of contrasting the cathedrals of France to our humble little buildings, to the cathedrals' detriment. Much was made of the pageantry of the cathedrals, the "costumes", the rituals, the candles, the stained glass, etc. Many people commented on how stark and cold the cathedrals were, and how they couldn't feel the Spirit there, whereas they did feel it in the stark, white, ordinary Institute.
Marc and I both came away feeling disturbed by the meeting. What about the admonition we have been given to seek out truth and light wherever we may encounter it? I for one am generally awestruck when I enter the cathedrals we visit. I find great beauty and a hushed reverence there that is very conducive to feeling the Spirit (with the exception of our recent visit to Sacre-Coeur, when they were having mass with thousands of tourists milling about -- that just felt wrong). And what of the attention to beauty and detail that we find in our LDS temples?
Marc felt the need to have a discussion with his students about the meeting and the attitudes that prevailed there. He urged them to have an open mind and heart while visiting the churches of Paris and just while living here in general. I think we will have a similar family home evening lesson with our children. One of our reasons for bringing them here is to have them experience a different culture and to see the beauty and the good they can take from it. I would love for them to take away a tolerance for others' differences and an appreciation for cultures different from our own. Now I just have to be a good example of that!
I was delighted to read Jill's post today about her experience at Notre Dame. Her feelings coincide exactly with mine (no great shock). I showed the post to Marc and he is going to tell his students about it for reinforcement of their discussion yesterday.
Going to church in France is always an adventure!
13 comments:
Very interesting post, I'm glad I wasn't one of the chumps who totally missed the boat on the beauty and spiritual nature of the grand old churches.
I remember studying Notre Dame (and many other churches) in my endless humanities classes so I recognized the way everything points heavenward. How the light from the stained glass windows is ethereal and heaven-like, and how the grandness of the buildings can't help but make us mortals feel small and humble. I loved experiencing all of that for myself even though it is different from my normal church-going experiences. Surely there's a place for pageantry.
Michelle,
I love this post. What an important concept that you understand yourself and were able to give to others. I'm so glad you put words to your thoughts and posted them. This is applicable in so many things, places, ways...thank you.
I love your posts from France.
oh, thank you for sharing your thoughts on this. i, for one, have grown up with the pageantry of quiet, dark cathedrals. there is a certain *hush* that fills me whenever i enter a cathedral or high church. how i would love a chance to visit some of the cathedrals in france!
I also found this to be interesting and saddening. I've seen many old beautiful church, many built upon what they feel to be the most significant parts of Christ ministry, where you stand in awe at it's beauty. Though it's not what we surround ourselves with it's hard to hear people talk in that way. We are all doing what we know to worship God.
I am glad that your husband is having a discussion about places of worship and reverance. I think that it speaks volumes of who you are when something like that will disturb you.
I agree with you. There is something sacred and holy to all these buildings that are dedicated to worship and for the love of Christ. Whether we agree with a certain teaching or not - it is a beautiful place of worship and love.
This was a very insightful post. I agree whole-heartedly about keeping an open mind, and finding that peace and beauty in ALL things spiritual.
oh, we often visit the national cathederal and just love it.
good for marc to take this as a teaching moment.
that picture jill took really is amazing!
and i love how everything in your blog is now in french... how long have i missed that.
I completely agree, how sad to miss the cultural experience, to not take the opportunity to learn about and respect the places that others have built to worship. I firmly believe that learning about what others believe and why enriches your own beliefes, it should not threaten them.
This post made me happy. I love that you are helping these students to open their minds! I think that is so important. How can you not be awestruck at the beauty and detail put into these buildings that people built to worship God -- long before the days of cranes and pre-fabricated elements. They are art, and should be appreciated for their beauty and their significance to the people who worship there. Good for you!
Hey Michelle,
enchantée: I am a first-time visitor (via many detours) to your blog, and I hail from Cergy (in your "new" Stake)...
I just read this one post, which reminded me of a relative and a friend who visited recently, who (when we visited Sacré Coeur--of all the religious sites probably my favorite, together with the Sainte Chapelle) mentioned this same emptiness, a lack of Spirit. While I love this (faithful LDS) relative dearly, I wondered if it wasn't a matter of "you get out of it what you put into it", 'cause I certainly do feel the Spirit there. Maybe not during their services (I have never actually stayed and participated in any of those)--but the sheer beauty, majesty and sacrifice that has gone into building a place to worship their God...how could that be lacking in Spirit?
I will definitely check back to read more of your posts, if you don't mind (as if you had a choice, lol).
bisous
Ah yes, the Ugly American inside his LDS cocoon. The sad thing is that testimony will probably be repeated in the person(s) home ward as a travelogue next month.
Your children are lucky for this experience. I'm glad your husband sought out the teaching moment as well.
Although I do have to say, the last time I was at Sacrament Meeting in Paris I whispered to my husband I would be willing to pay 11% if it got the saints in France some A/C!:)
I just notice you're doing your dates in french! I love it!
Post a Comment